• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Falbo Bros Pizzeria

At Falbo Bros Pizzeria, a beloved local eatery in Hartland, we share a passion for crafting the perfect pizza. Born from a commitment to quality and community, our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, including renowned stuffed pizzas and savory subs. With a focus on fresh ingredients and generous portions, each dish promises a delightful experience. Our friendly staff strives to create a warm, inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families, friends, and groups. Whether you prefer dining in, taking out, or catering your next event, Falbo Bros Pizzeria delights in serving you with excellence, one slice at a time.

Falbo Bros Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Carrol L.
Carrol L.

At first I was hesitant to go back after I heard about new ownership but I can absolutely say the pizza has done nothing but get better. I got a stuffed meat eaters pizza and it was perfect, everything from the crust to the topping. Hands down the best pizza I have ever had. I was also pleased to hear that with the new ownership the price will be going DOWN!!! I have never heard that before, especially in today's day and age. I am also very excited about the new app of the months that they just started doing, I can't wait to try the arancini balls that are coming in July. This is easily the best pizza and maybe one of the best restaurants I have ever been to. Definitely recommend.

Grace M.
Grace M.

Good food, good price. Staff are sometimes not so engaging, but generally friendly. Pizza by the slice at noon time isn't always hot, but quality is there.

Andy K.
Andy K.

This is a solid pizzeria in the heart of Hartland, one of a few of a local chain. My work and I ordered from here for a staff in-service day, and the service provided by the restaurant, both during the ordering process and the delivery itself, was great. We had a large order, as we were feeding 16 people, and the staff member who took the order over the phone was very patient and attentive, answering any questions I had quickly and allowing several substitutions/alterations to occur. The guy who delivered it a few days later to us at work was super helpful--instead of just handing the order to us at the door and scramming, he took time to carry all of the food and drinks inside and helped us set it up around a large table. He made sure we had everything we needed before he left, and he left a warming bag with us to keep some of the smaller food in before we busted into the boxes (we returned it later, and there wasn't a certain time by when we had to get it back, which was nice). The food itself was pretty good--the pizzas were a little greasy, and the cheese bread a little overcooked, but otherwise it was excellent food. We got orders of cheese curds, garlic bread, cheese bread, pizzas, sandwiches, and a salad, and all of the food was fresh and/or hot, with nothing seeming like it had been cooked far in advance and then left under a heat lamp until the order was ran over to us. I personally ordered a chicken parmesan sandwich, and it was excellent--the chicken tenders in the sandwich were crispy and warm, the marinara sauce not too sweet, and the cheese perfectly melted. Based on the ease of ordering and the great delivery service, combined with the really good taste of the food, we plan on using these guys again at my work for catering purposes, and I wouldn't mind getting an order here myself someday when I'm around town, especially one of their many specialty sandwiches, which all have pretty phenomenal names IMO.

N G.
N G.

Stuffed bbq chicken pizza is legit!! Excellent flavor...perfect! Order it and then head downstairs to Melms microbrewery for a beer. Falbo will bring it to you!

Location

Welcome to Falbo Bros Pizzeria! Nestled in the heart of Hartland, WI, at 418 Merton Ave, Falbo Bros Pizzeria has carved out a niche as a go-to destination for pizza lovers and casual diners alike. Known for its delightful blend of traditional and innovative pizza varieties, this local spot has garnered a loyal following that continues to grow, particularly under new ownership.

At Falbo Bros, you can expect not just great pizza but a complete dining experience. They offer a plethora of amenities, including:

  • Convenient delivery and takeout
  • Reservations for those special occasions
  • A diverse selection of vegetarian options
  • Wheelchair accessibility
  • Free Wi-Fi for the connected diner
  • Outdoor seating that’s perfect for warmer days
  • And much more!

Falbo Bros specializes in mouthwatering pizzas that cater to every palate, from classic cheese to creative specialty pies. Customers rave about the Stuffed Meat Eaters Pizza, which one enthusiastic patron deemed "hands down the best pizza I have ever had." The quality of the ingredients shines through, ensuring each bite bursts with flavor.

Don't overlook their delightful starters! The Garlic Bread & Sticks and Falbo's Famous Cheesestix come highly recommended, as do their signature items like the Falzone—a calzone twist filled with your choice of three toppings, complemented by their delicious marinara sauce.

The dessert selection is equally tempting, featuring creations like Deep Fried Cheesecake and the classic Cannoli, perfect for concluding your meal on a sweet note.

Customer experiences echo a commitment to quality and service. One patron noted how the staff made catering for a large group effortless—taking care of everything from order accuracy to delivery right into their workspace, illustrating the restaurant's dedication to customer satisfaction.

With a casual atmosphere and moderate noise levels, Falbo Bros Pizzeria provides a perfect backdrop for family dinners or groups of friends. Their commitment to community extends even to their utilization of technology—QR code menus and ASL proficiency reflect an inclusive environment that caters to everyone.

The next time you're in Hartland, treat yourself to a slice (or a whole pie) at Falbo Bros Pizzeria. Whether dining in or ordering out, you’ll experience pizza perfection backed by unmatched service!

For inquiries or to place an order, call them at (262) 367-2700. Discover your new favorite pizzeria at Falbo Bros!